Letter to Senator Sheilds

wethepeopleDear Senator Shields,


As I testified last Wednesday, I simply cannot imagine how to practice medicine and educate parents about vaccines without the informed consent process.  A medical procedure must include informed consent that involves giving the risks and the benefits and the alternatives to the procedure and doing nothing or not doing the procedure always needs to be an option regardless of wether or not you the doctor think it is the best option.


As a Pediatrician in Portland for the past 26 years with likely the fastest growing practice starting with 1000 patients in 2008 to 11,000 patients in the past 6 years and now about 500 newborns a year – I speak for a growing number of our parents when I say that they will not under any circumstance agree to inject 250 micrograms of aluminum into their newborn with the Hepatitis B shot, when mom does not have hepatitis B. That would be the deliberate and knowing poisoning of their newborn where there is absolutely no benefit, and yet it is one of the mandated vaccines that will be forced on babies if SB442 passes.


I think my experience with parents is worth sharing.  Educated and informed parents learn about the risks and the benefits of vaccines.  Most don’t understand why their newborn would be forced to get the Hepatitis B vaccine day one, when they already know that mom is hepatitis B negative and often immune, having had the vaccines herself. The sad truth, lost in the sound bite debate we see in the press and even the courts and between doctors, is that in my practice it is the parents who are better informed than most of my peers.


Due to my scientific and logical approach, I get most of the paranoid, scared, non-vaccinators, and well educated parents coming to me for care.  I’m able to get most to do those vaccines that are most important, often when they had no intentions of vaccinating. Most of these families will go underground if forced to get vaccines.  I wouldn’t go to a doctor if I thought I might be forced to get a toxic injection I didn’t need?


We can promote better public health by educating our citizens on the risks and the benefits.  I can assure you if we have several cases of measles in the Portland area, almost every parent in my practice who had a child that was not yet immune (vaccinated) would be coming in for the MMR vaccine.  The system we have works. If there was a case of measles in a school, our public health officials already can swoop in and exclude every child not fully vaccinated or having proof of measles immunity.


SB442 – 3 will not make us safer, it will simply push more people away from pediatricians, and will start the undoing of our vaccine policies as we know them today.  As the facts reach more and more people, we will have greater and greater numbers refusing all vaccines.


When informed consent, is part of the equation, then doctors and pediatricians like myself have the oportunity to educate.  We may not always agree on which information to share with patients, but at least we are able to have the process of education on risks, benefits and alternatives. Without that, we simply have state mandated medical procedures being performed on citizens potentially against their will.  I cannot imagine how badly that will go.


I am willing to share with you in depth the medical studies that show dangers of injecting aluminum to babies for example.  I am willing to discuss this personally with you if you wish. As one of the few pediatricians who is pro-vaccine but not in favor of the CDC schedule as it is today (mostly because of the Hepatitis B – newborn issue) – I am often misquoted as being anti-vaccine.  Nothing is farther from the truth.  I am in favor of informed consent, logical personal health choices that use your family history and personal genetics to make the best decision for your family and your child’s health.


The designation of Oregon as being in a state of emergency on passage of SB442 is a grave error.  First, there is no emergency and secondly nothing good comes from giving someone emergency powers when there isn’t an emergency.  We have had one case of measles linked to the California cases.  Not one person caught measles from that man.  In recent years we had a case go through the Portland airport – no one got measles form that case.  We had a case where the infected person attended multiple tennis venues in the Portland area.  Not a single case resulted from that one.  Measles in Oregon is less than 1/million.  The death rate if you catch measles is 1/1000 to 1/2000.  Thus I cannot see the emergency.  Not a single death in the USA in a decade.


I hope you will vote no on SB442. This bill will be the beginning of the end for personal health freedoms, but what I fear the most is that those politicians who side with this bill, will loose credibility.  I am aware of your fine track record of common sense and upholding the freedoms of our citizens. This should be a non-partisan issue.  I suspect we are very similar in most of our beliefs based on your past track record. I see the assault on medical freedom and the informed consent process reaching the proportions of MLK and civil rights.  I hope we get it right from the start.  I have never been political, but this challenge to our children’s health and freedom I cannot ignore.


Thank-you for taking the time to read this.  Please vote no on SB442-3


Dr. Paul


  • S

    Dr. Paul – I cannot express enough thanks to you for your advocacy. You are a hero to my family.

  • Thank you so much for all of your time you have put in on this issue to testify as well as inform parents about their rights being threatened by the legislature.

  • Alex Edwardsen

    Bravo, Dr. Thomas! Very well said. I, myself, and pro-vaccine/the current schedule, but I am anti the passing of this outrageous bill. I have an 18 month old son, and was appalled that the hospital mandated to me that he must have a Hep B vaccine. This proposed infringement on our personal medical autonomy is the tip of an enormous and terrifying iceberg. Thank you!

  • You are entering the lions den. I admire your courage. Thanks for speaking up.

  • MaryF

    Dr Paul, thank you from the bottom of my heart for working hard to protect our children.

    I saw you speak last week & have followed you here for a long time. I am thankful that you feel strongly enough to speak out!

  • Megan McDonald

    Dr. Paul – How do we help? If I write a letter, where should I send it?

    My daughter (22 months) is a patient at your clinic – she is happy, healthy and extremely smart. I am exactly the parent you describe, I fully support vaccines, heard immunity and science, just not at the CDC’s recommended rate. My daughter is up to date on many of the CDC’s recommended vaccines now and by the time my daughter starts public school, she will be completely up to date with the CDC schedule. We have talked about having a second child, but may decide not to if I would be forced to poison that baby with the Hep B vaccine at the hospital.

    Please let me know what I may be able to do to help.

    • The senators in the health committee are the ones to send that exact message you sent me. They need to hear that intelligent parents who vaccinate slowly are not only helping their own children minimize toxins during key brain development years, but they are also going to protect herd immunity and will not put anyone elses child in danger, for example, by waiting until age 3-5 to give the Hepatitis B or checking that child is immune to measles rather than giving the second MMR etc. Thanks More blogs in the next few days on what you can do

  • Teresa

    Perfectly written! Thank you.

  • Katie Kuzkin

    Thank you Dr. Paul.

  • Megan Mcdonald,
    Please find check out our website or facebook page to find out how to go about helping defeat SB 442-3
    Thank you Dr. Paul for speaking out against this legislation!

  • RoxanaN

    Thank you Dr. Thomas! You are brave for speaking out for us. My son and my yet unborn child thank you from their hearts!!!
    Let us know how we can help on this.

Reply To This Post